YeastMatch

Substitute for Amarillo: hops like Amarillo

Amarillo (United States)

If you cannot get Amarillo, this is the closest hop and what changes in the beer.

Close, with a caveat. Citra is the nearest substitute for Amarillo, but the aroma shifts.
Substitution
Amarillo (United States)
Citra

Original hop vs substitute

Out ofAmarillo (United States)
Closest substituteCitra
Original alpha acid6.7 to 11 %
Original myrcene16.7 to 70 %
Original aromaFruity apricot, peach, ripe banana and honeydew melon with tart grapefruit and lime

Notes

If Amarillo is out, Citra is the nearest bright substitute, though the character shifts.

Citra brings more grapefruit and tropical punch where Amarillo is softer orange, apricot and melon; a Citra-and-Cascade blend gets closer to Amarillo's gentler stone-fruit tone.

What to buy instead

Related

Sources: BarthHaas Amarillo hop variety profile · BarthHaas Citra hop variety profile · BarthHaas Cascade hop variety profile